Skip to main content

A Fair and Consistent Approach to AI & Greenscreen Content

Dear Luke, I completely respect the choice of those who don't wish to see photographs using greenscreen or AI-generated backgrounds, and I understand that Primfeed needs rules. At the same time, I wonder whether there could be a way to respect those who do enjoy this type of creative work as well... perhaps through a simple choice or setting that allows people to decide what they wish to see.

What concerns me most is consistency. AI-generated backgrounds are sold as Second Life products in-world and on the Marketplace, and we can also see examples of AI backgrounds and composited images appearing in the Public Gallery. I completely understand that the rules may still be under discussion, but I hope there can ultimately be a clear and consistent approach that applies equally to everyone.

I also hope that the impact on bloggers and the creators who sponsor them can be taken into consideration. Perhaps this is something that could be put to the community through a vote or poll, so that different perspectives can be heard?

You've created something with enormous potential Luke, and I genuinely believe it could become something truly magical. I would simply love to see that potential embraced in a way that gives people as much creative freedom and choice as possible. ❤️

1 comment

Log in to comment and vote

Comments1

  • Callie Hareshide

    •

    Oct 9

    Thank you Luke for the amazing photo platform with all its features! I was happy to escape the limitations we’ve all experienced on Flickr. For the majority of our experienced photographers & bloggers, “green screen” was and is the way to go for inworld fashion shots for many years, which still focuses on the “main object”, with advanced editing in Photoshop. AI became part of inworld backdrops, on products with AI generated textures. Creativity on the inworld shot was always the most important part, accepted by most platforms. Not ONLY bloggers or phtographers, but EVERYONE who buy products on Second Life’s Market Place would not know they just bought products with AI geenerated backgrounds or textures, to be used in photography on Primfeed, because the creators & sellers never say it’s AI generated. Whether it’s a good or bad thing, it won’t disappear unfortunately and fortunately. In many of my posts in the past i was using green screen, google images in the background, which passed your detectors(apologies). My point is: taking a shot from a scene inworld which includes objects containing AI + hours of work in editing is not different than taking a raw shot inworld and post it on Primfeed, not less creative, but allows room for more creativity, where a normal and bare inworld scene fall short. Please reconsider the rules about AI, everybody gets the benefit of it.